Rising Crime in Bali Sparks Concern Over Changing Tourist Demographics
Bali, Indonesia — The Indonesian island of Bali, long renowned for its serene landscapes and peaceful tourism, is facing a growing wave of crime that has locals questioning whether the quality of tourists is deteriorating. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, the island has seen significant changes in the makeup of its visitors, with an influx of backpackers, digital nomads, and long-term expats contributing to a surge in criminal activities.
Increase in Crime Among Foreign Visitors
Bali police have reported a 16% increase in foreigners involved in criminal offenses this year. In 2024, there have been 226 cases involving foreign nationals, up from 194 in 2023. These crimes range from cybercrime and narcotics offenses to violent crimes and land fraud. This upward trend has caused concern among local officials and residents who previously enjoyed the island’s reputation as a safe destination.
Bali politician Agung Bagus Pratiksa Linggih noted that the quality of tourists appears to be declining, attributing this trend to the rapid growth of illegal homestays. These unregulated accommodations allow low-budget visitors to stay for extended periods, potentially facilitating criminal activities. “The quality of tourists coming to Bali is decreasing,” he stated, emphasizing the strain on local facilities and infrastructure trying to keep pace with the surge.
Changing Tourist Landscape and Its Impact
Long-time Bali resident Paul Werner, owner of PaD Bar and Grill in Kuta, remarked on the changing tourist dynamic since the pandemic. An influx of money has flowed into the island, but alongside it, Werner observed more instances of drunken altercations, especially involving Western tourists. “Crime generally follows where the tourists are going. It is mainly a lot of drunk westerners not knowing how to level out their alcohol and fighting over nothing,” he said. Werner questioned, “Is [crime here] getting worse, or is it the Australians coming here getting worse?”
The island was recently shaken by a high-profile violent crime: the fatal shooting of Melbourne man Zivan Radmanovic, 32, who was killed at his villa in Munggu in what police allege was a premeditated attack involving three Australians currently charged with murder. This incident is still under investigation, and authorities have not ruled out the possibility that Radmanovic may not have been the intended target.
Concerns Over Organized Crime and Illegal Activities
Historically, Bali’s connection to Australia has occasionally been shadowed by incidents of misbehavior and crime, notably highlighted by drug smuggling and the notorious Bali bombings in 2002. However, locals argue that the recent visibility of organized crime is unprecedented.
Melbourne resident Jan Laczynski, who tragically lost five friends in the 2002 bombings, expressed alarm at the recent violence. “Shootings in Bali are unheard of. In Melbourne, they happen all the time, but not here,” he said, questioning the source of firearms and suggesting the emergence of an underworld market.
Despite Indonesia’s reputation for low crime rates—recording only three firearm-related crimes in Bali in 2023—the increase in crimes involving foreigners indicates shifting patterns. Bali social justice advocate Piter Panjaitan highlighted various criminal activities, including meth labs, villa robberies, crypto scams, property fraud, and ATM thefts, often connected to Russian and Eastern European groups. He attributed the rise to Bali’s open-door tourism policy, economic hardship post-pandemic, corruption, and weak law enforcement.
“We need quality tourism, not just quantity,” Panjaitan emphasized, calling for enhanced immigration controls, improved police training focused on tourist areas, and greater international cooperation.
Experts Warn of Escalating Organized Crime
Criminology expert Adrianus Meliala from the University of Indonesia warned that Bali might soon witness escalating organized crime rates as more foreigners settle long-term, sometimes importing conflicts and criminal elements from abroad. He described Bali as an attractive hub for criminal groups due to its proximity to Australia, affordability, and the challenges local law enforcement faces.
“Organised crime is not just terrorism or people smuggling anymore—it’s broader now, and Bali is attractive economically and logistically,” Meliala said.
Impact on Local Communities and Infrastructure
The island continues to attract around half a million tourists monthly, along with a growing number of digital nomads. The provincial government aims to reach 6.5 million international visitors this year. However, local infrastructure and community safety measures struggle to keep pace with this rapid growth.
In Munggu village, where the recent shooting occurred, chief I Ketut Darta described how 400 villas, many owned by foreigners, have been rapidly constructed in 2024, transforming agricultural land and raising concerns about security. “There has never been a shooting here, even fights are rare,” Darta said, adding that the community conducts 24-hour patrols to protect tourism, the lifeblood of their area.
Looking Ahead
The evolving dynamics of Bali’s tourism industry raise challenging questions about balancing economic growth with social stability and safety. As local leaders advocate for stricter regulations and improved law enforcement, many hope to preserve the island’s peaceful charm while confronting the realities of a changing visitor demographic.
For now, Bali’s residents remain vigilant, hoping their island can navigate these new challenges while maintaining its status as a beloved destination for travelers worldwide.
Add a comment