Rising Crime in Bali Raises Concerns Among Locals Over Changing Tourist Demographics
Bali, Indonesia – As the number of tourists returning to Bali surges post-pandemic, local residents and officials are voicing concerns over a noticeable uptick in crime, coupled with a shift in the type and behavior of visitors frequenting the island. The once tranquil tourist destination known for its serenity is now grappling with a growing criminal undercurrent that some attribute to changes in the tourist makeup, including an influx of backpackers, digital nomads, and expatriates.
Increase in Foreign-Related Crime
Bali police have reported a 16% rise in crimes involving foreigners this year, with 226 cases recorded in 2024 compared to 194 in 2023. These crimes span a wide spectrum, from cybercrime and narcotics offenses to violent crimes and property fraud. The police continue to investigate high-profile cases such as the recent murder of Melbourne man Zivan Radmanovic, whose fatal shooting in June shocked both the local community and international observers. Three Australians have been charged in connection with the case, though investigations remain ongoing.
Changing Tourist Profile and Its Impact
Local politicians and business owners have noted a transformation in Bali’s tourism landscape since the Covid-19 pandemic. Agung Bagus Pratiksa Linggih, a Bali politician, pointed out that the surge in illegal homestays is enabling long-term stays by low-budget travelers, which he says is linked to a decline in the overall “quality” of tourists.
Paul Werner, along with running a popular bar in Kuta, has resided in Bali for a decade and witnessed firsthand the shift in visitor dynamics. He remarks that much of the crime appears linked to intoxicated Western tourists engaging in disorderly conduct and fights. Werner questions whether the issue lies with Bali’s safety deteriorating or if some tourists are simply behaving worse than before.
Concerns Over Organized Crime and Law Enforcement Challenges
While Indonesia maintains one of the lowest crime rates globally, recent developments suggest a growing visibility of organized crime on Bali. Jan Laczynski, a Melbourne resident who lost friends in the 2002 Bali bombings, observes that gun-related violence is becoming a concerning possibility for the island, a place previously free of such incidents.
Experts like criminology professor Adrianus Meliala warn that Bali’s changing demographics, with more foreigners settling long-term, could invite criminal elements from abroad. “Bali is close, it’s cheap, and law enforcement struggles to keep up,” Meliala notes. He emphasizes that organized crime now encompasses more than traditional activities like terrorism or smuggling, making Bali a prime target for criminal groups.
Local Response and Calls for Reform
Social justice advocate Piter Panjaitan outlines issues such as methamphetamine labs, villa burglaries, crypto scams, and ATM thefts, often linked to Russian and Eastern European criminal groups. Panjaitan criticizes Bali’s open-door tourism policy and attributes the crime rise partly to economic desperation following the pandemic, coupled with local corruption and weak enforcement.
He advocates for enhanced immigration controls, improved police training in tourist hubs, and stronger cooperation with international authorities. According to Panjaitan, the focus should shift towards attracting “quality tourism, not just quantity.”
Pressure on Infrastructure and Community Impact
With about half a million tourists visiting Bali monthly, the provincial government aims to attract a record 6.5 million international visitors in 2025. However, rapid development to accommodate this growth is straining local communities and infrastructure. In Munggu village, for example, over 400 new villas have appeared this year, many owned by foreigners, drastically altering the rural landscape and reducing agricultural land.
Village chief I Ketut Darta expresses concern about the potential ramifications of this fast-paced change on local security, highlighting that violent incidents had been exceedingly rare in his community. “We patrol our village 24 hours a day. Tourism is our lifeblood, and we must protect it,” Darta affirms.
As Bali navigates the challenges of reviving its tourism economy, residents and officials alike urge a balanced approach that fosters safe, sustainable tourism while addressing emerging criminal threats. The island’s future as a peaceful paradise may well depend on how effectively these issues are managed in the months and years ahead.
Add a comment