Bali Tourism Surges Amid Rising Concerns Over Foreigners’ Violations
Denpasar, Bali – Bali has reaffirmed its status as Indonesia’s premier tourism destination, welcoming 6.3 million foreign visitors in 2024—surpassing pre-pandemic levels recorded in 2019. The island, famed as the "Island of the Gods," attracted nearly half of the country’s overall 13.9 million foreign tourists, significantly contributing to national revenue.
Bali Governor Wayan Koster revealed that the island accounted for 44 percent of Indonesia’s tourism foreign exchange earnings in 2024, amounting to approximately Rp107 trillion (US$6.69 billion). This figure forms a substantial part of Indonesia’s total tourism earnings of US$16.71 billion (Rp280 trillion) reported by Bank Indonesia. These robust inflows underscore Bali’s critical role as a barometer for the country’s tourism sector recovery and growth.
Tourism Growth Balanced by Enforcement Challenges
Despite these positive developments, concerns have emerged over the behavior and compliance of some foreign visitors. The Directorate General of Immigration reported that between January and September 2024, 378 foreigners were deported from Bali—a rise from 335 deportations in 2023. These deportations, primarily linked to visa overstays and misuse, represent just a fraction of the millions of tourists but signal growing enforcement challenges.
Nationally, from January through July 2025, immigration authorities recorded 2,669 deportations and 2,009 detentions of foreign nationals. Legal proceedings were initiated against 62 foreigners between November 2024 and July 2025. Common infractions include overstaying visas, working on tourist visas, misusing investor visas without actual investments, engaging in transnational crimes, violating local regulations, and disrespecting Balinese cultural norms.
Strengthening Monitoring and Law Enforcement Efforts
To address these challenges, Bali authorities have intensified monitoring and enforcement through discreet operations to prevent suspects from escaping. The multi-agency Foreigners Supervision Team (Tim Pora) operates at both national and regional levels, coordinating efforts and monitoring social media platforms where violations frequently surface.
Several key operations have bolstered enforcement:
- Operation “Jagratara” apprehended 914 foreign nationals in May 2024 and 1,293 in July 2024.
- Operation “Bali Becik” in June 2024 targeted suspected members of international cybercrime syndicates, capturing 103 individuals.
- Other initiatives include Operation Wira Waspada and the establishment of special task forces focused on illegal activities.
Most recently, an Immigration Patrol Task Force was launched on August 1, 2025. Involving 100 immigration officers supported by the Indonesian Military (TNI), National Police (Polri), Public Order and Security Agency (Satpol PP), and traditional Balinese security guards (pecalang), the task force conducts patrols at key tourist locations throughout August. Equipped with body cameras and protective gear, officers are authorized to temporarily seize immigration documents from suspected violators for further investigation.
Ongoing Challenges: Illegal Accommodations and Corruption
Authorities face notable obstacles in foreigner regulation enforcement. One significant issue is the proliferation of unlicensed accommodations that evade foreign guest reporting, complicating monitoring efforts and causing considerable tax revenue losses. Bali Hotel and Restaurant Association (PHRI) Secretary-General Perry Markus has called for stronger government oversight and firmer action against illegal lodging operations.
Corruption within enforcement ranks also jeopardizes credibility. Recently, Bali police arrested two immigration officers who allegedly colluded with Russian nationals in extorting and assaulting a Lithuanian citizen. The officers reportedly used threats of deportation and kidnapping to intimidate the victim. The Minister of Immigration and Corrections, Agus Andrianto, announced plans to dismiss the involved officers following court rulings and emphasized the need for integrity and ethical conduct among immigration personnel.
A Call for Balanced Strategies
While Bali’s tourism recovery benefits from eased foreign entry protocols, officials stress the necessity of balanced strategies that enhance legal compliance. This includes stricter permit issuance, improved cross-sector cooperation, expanded use of technology for foreigner monitoring, and capacity-building training programs for immigration officers.
As tourism continues to rebound, authorities remain vigilant in maintaining Bali’s reputation as a safe and welcoming destination, ensuring both visitors and local communities coexist harmoniously.
Keywords: Bali tourism, foreigner violations, deportations Bali, immigration enforcement, visa overstays, illegal accommodations, Bali task force, Indonesia tourism revenue
Add a comment