Rising Crime Rates in Bali Spark Local Concerns Over Changing Tourist Demographics
Bali, Indonesia — As the island’s tourism industry rebounds from the COVID-19 pandemic, locals are expressing growing unease over an uptick in crime and questioning whether the character of incoming tourists has deteriorated. The surge in criminal incidents, especially involving foreigners, is prompting calls for tighter regulation and renewed focus on maintaining Bali’s reputation as a peaceful destination.
Rising Crime Linked to Changing Tourist Profiles
Bali police have reported a 16% increase in the number of foreigners implicated in criminal activities, with 226 cases recorded in 2024 compared to 194 in 2023. These offenses range from cybercrime and narcotics to violent crimes and property fraud.
According to Bali politician Agung Bagus Pratiksa Linggih, the post-pandemic influx of long-term, low-budget foreign visitors—such as backpackers, digital nomads, and expatriates—has created new challenges for the island’s infrastructure and security. Pratiksa noted a rise in illegal homestays, which enable budget travelers to stay extended periods, contributing to a perceived decline in the “quality” of tourists.
Paul Werner, owner of PaD Bar and Grill in Kuta and a resident for the past decade, also observed changes since the pandemic. He pointed to the correlation between tourist hotspots and crime, remarking that many issues stem from intoxicated Western visitors involved in altercations. “Is [crime here] getting worse, or is it the Australians coming here getting worse?” Werner questioned, reflecting local debates sparked by recent incidents.
Notable Incidents Amplify Concerns
The island was shaken in June by the fatal shooting of Melbourne resident Zivan Radmanovic, 32, whose murder in a villa in Munggu—currently under investigation with three Australians charged—has heightened fears about escalating violent crime.
Bali has historically attracted misbehaving Australian tourists, but the post-pandemic period appears to have ushered in a broader and more diverse criminal element. Melbourne native Jan Laczynski, who lost friends in the 2002 Bali bombings, expressed surprise at the emergence of shootings—an uncommon occurrence in Bali compared to urban centers like Melbourne—and speculated about the growth of an illicit gun market and underworld activities.
Calls for Stronger Law Enforcement and Quality Tourism
While Indonesia generally maintains one of the world’s lowest crime rates, with Bali recording only three firearm-related crimes in 2023 according to the Central Statistics Agency, local authorities acknowledge challenges in managing the rising crime trend among tourists.
Social justice advocate Piter Panjaitan highlighted troubling activities involving meth labs, villa robberies, cryptocurrency scams, and property fraud, often linked to Russian and Eastern European groups. Panjaitan attributed the problem to Bali’s open-door tourism policies, weak enforcement, corruption, and economic pressures following the pandemic. He urged for enhanced immigration controls, police training in tourist zones, and international cooperation to curb criminal enterprises, advocating for “quality tourism, not just quantity.”
Criminology expert Professor Adrianus Meliala warned of the potential escalation of organised crime as more foreigners settle long-term on the island, sometimes importing conflicts and criminal networks. Meliala described Bali as a strategic location for criminal groups due to its proximity, affordability, and law enforcement limitations.
Rapid Development and Its Impact on Local Communities
Tourism authorities report around half a million visitors arrive monthly, and the provincial government aims for a record 6.5 million international tourists this year. This rapid growth has fueled property development, with village chief I Ketut Darta noting that 400 new villas were constructed in Munggu in just one year, mostly foreign-owned, leading to significant loss of agricultural land.
Darta expressed concern about the social impact of this rapid change, emphasizing that violent crime has been historically rare in his community. “We patrol our village 24 hours a day. Tourism is our lifeblood, and we must protect it,” he said.
Looking Ahead
As Bali grapples with balancing tourism growth and public safety, stakeholders are calling for a more sustainable approach that prioritizes visitor quality and stronger governance. The island’s unique cultural heritage and natural beauty depend on maintaining a safe and welcoming environment, even as the demographics of its visitors continue to evolve.
Local voices suggest that without proactive measures, the criminal underbelly could deepen, threatening both Bali’s economic vitality and its cherished peaceful atmosphere.
Add a comment